Cascabel Working Group - Public Comments on the SunZia Project

Cascabel Working Group
A grassroots organization concerned with the cultural and ecological integrity of the lower/middle San Pedro Valley

Home

News & Events ➤

Current 2016 - 2018 2013 - 2015 2009 - 2012

Talking Points ➤

Eleven Big Issues Conservation Efforts Talking Points 1 Talking Points 2 (ACC)

CWG Authored Docs ➤

2010 DEIS Contributions

BLM Correspondence ➤

Request for Public Hearing/Comment Period Extension CWG - on the Southline Transmission Project

Our Research ➤

Overview An Unnecessary High-Risk Project? Hypothetical Jobs - SunZia Economic Impact 1 Hypothetical Jobs - SunZia Economic Impact 2 Albuquerque Journal on Hypothetical Jobs (above) Letter to DOI: Why SunZia Could Fail Financially Attachments for above (History / Proposed Uses SWAT/Bowie Background - Renewable Capacity Limits How Much Renewable Can SunZia Carry? Eastern AZ Transmission Projects The Southline - Possible Alternative to SunZia High Plains Express and SunZia Early History of SunZia Bowie Gas Plant and SunZia Transmission Needs of Bowie AZ/NM Wind Production vs Electric Comsumption 1 AZ/NM Wind Production vs Electric Comsumption 2

2012 DEIS Response 2013 DEIS Rebuttal of BLM & FEIS Protest

Permits Issued ➤

2021 Final Environmental Impact Statement (index) 2015 BLM Rec of Decision, ROD

BLM 2015 FEIS ➤

2015 FEIS CWG / Coalition Response 2015 FEIS Response from Peter Else

2015 CEC (Arizona) ➤

Certificate of Environmental Compatibility Chairman Little's Dissent, starting on pg 6 2020 CWG Letter to ACC: CEC non-compliance

2021 Amendment ➤

FEIS (index)

FEIS Protests ➤

Coalition Protest Archaeology Southwest

DEIS DEIS Appendices

DEIS Comments ➤

LSPWA, CWG, CCA, & Others Archaeology Southwest

BLM Scoping Report 1 BLM Scoping Report 2

Scoping Comments ➤

LSPWSA Southline Trnms Project

2012 DEIS Comments ➤

Notice of Disclosure Reponse Index/Overview

From CWG ➤

Primary Response Letter Primary Response Attachments San Pedro Comments Biodiversity Metric Bowie-SunZia Connection Letter Bowie-SunZia Documentation Economic Analysis Past Economic Reports Overview of DEIS Deficiencies and Issues Transmission Congestion in NM Congestion - supporting figures Congestion - WECC Path 47 Aravaipa Comments Comments on Oversights

Organizations ➤

Archaeology Southwest Audubon Arizona Audubon New Mexico Audubon Tucson/Huachuca Center for Biological Diversity Coalition for Sonoran Desert Protection Defenders of Wildlife and Partners (includes co-signers Coalition for Sonoran Desert Protection, Tucson Audubon Society and the Sky Island Alliance) Environmental Protection Agency (Region 6) Friends of the Aravaipa Region Grand Canyon Chapter of the Sierra Club The Nature Conservancy NRCD (Redington/Winkelman): Comments NRCD (Redington/Winkelman): Exhibits Peter Warshall and Associates Pima County Russ Lowes, Energy Chair, Rincon Chapter, Sierra Club (includes the Center for Biological Diversity) Sky Island Alliance Comments Sky Island Alliance - Aravaipa Ecosystem Mgmt Plan U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service The Wilderness Society (includes the Sonoran Institute, Audubon Rockies, Western Resource Advocates, New Mexico Wilderness Alliance, Arizona Wilderness Coalition, and the Natural Resources Defense Council)

Individuals ➤

Jon Sjogren 1 Jon Sjogren 2 Marshall Magruder Comments Marshall Magruder Attachment Gammons Gulch Clifford Baker Bonner McAllester

SunZia (Wray) ➤

Wray Comment 1 Wray Comment 2 Wray Comment 3 Wray Comment 4 Wray Comment 5

Counties / Chambers ➤

Cochise County Board of Supervisors Graham County Board of Supervisors Greenlee County Board of Supervisors Pinal County Board of Supervisors Benson City Council Bowie Chamber of Commerce Graham County Chamber of Commerce Willcox City Council

2010 Scoping Cmnts ➤

Comments From CWG ➤

CWG Letter 1 CWG Letter 2

From Organizations From Govt Officials From Individuals

Maps, Timeline➤

Arizona near Cascabel Detail Maps & Timeline

Background, Acronyms

More ➤

Brochure, Presentations SunZia's Lobbying NRCD's Petition Arizona SB1517: defeated FAQ

The following comments have been sent to BLM and/or AZ Corporation Commission posted here with permission. We hope that these will provide you with varying perspectives and opinions so that they may help your formulate your own comment to these agencies. Please feel free to send us your comments to post.

Individuals
Research Engineer, Jon Sjogren's excellent BLM Comments
(102 KB PDF)

Jon Sjogren's personal comments to AZ Corporation Commission
(28.7 KB PDF)

Bonner McAllester's letter to the BLM and her op-ed piece David and Goliath in the Desert

Joe Baker's BLM comments

Richard Winslow's BLM comments

Mick Meader's comments to Cochise County Board of Supervisors
(102 KB PDF)

Chris Eastoe's comments to BLM
(782 KB PDF)

Eddie Araiza comments to BLM
(40 KB PDF)

David Omick's comments to BLM
(25 KB PDF)

Alan and Krista Binnie's comments to BLM
(39 KB PDF)

Brandon Wert's comments to BLM
(40 KB PDF)

Jacquie Dale's comments to BLM
(39 KB PDF)

James Bergstrom's comments to BLM
(48 KB PDF)

Gilbert Urias's comments to BLM
(42 KB PDF)

Jackelynn Wert's comments to BLM
(4 KB PDF)

Luci Wert's comments to BLM
(4 KB PDF)

Barbara Clark's comments to BLM
(44 KB PDF)

Lynn Smith-Lovin's comments to BLM
(59 KB PDF)

Bob Evan's comment to BLM
(42 KB PDF)

Bob Evan's 2nd comment to BLM
(42 KB PDF)

Leslie and Ross Maynard's comments to BLM
(37 KB PDF)

Arden and Elizabeth Buck's comments to BLM
(38 KB PDF)